Abuse, including threats to stab the newly-elected leader of South Kesteven District Council, led to a secret ballot on a local hunt.
Councillor Virginia Moran called on the authority to withdraw any non-statutory support for the annual Belvoir Hunt.
She wanted the authority to reject permission for the use SKDC assets in connection with the hunt, to force them to name any charity they were collecting for and to ensure costs associated with the event were recovered.
However, prior to the motion, council leader Kelham Cooke stood to call for the vote to be held as a secret ballot.
The motion was rejected 22 against, 12 for and two abstain.
He said: “There has been a significant amount of abuse and intimidation of individual councillors from across this chamber.
“I have had phone calls and messages from individuals concerned about their safety within their own homes with regard to this motion.
“I don’t do this lightly, but I am genuinely concerned for councillors within this room. I myself live on my own and have already had threatening messages online calling for me to be stabbed and calling me other names which is not appropriate.”
Councillor Moran’s motion followed the conclusion of a criminal case earlier this year, which saw a now-former employee of the hunt convicted of assaulting two people who were monitoring the hunt in 2016.
The incident saw one of the victims suffer a broken neck and broken vertebrae, while the other suffered cuts and bruises, bleeding down the side of his head and concussion.
The hunt itself did not admit liability for the assault, but did pay more than £48,000 in compensation.
Four other attackers involved in the assault were never identified or caught.
Councillor Moran told councillors she was “very disturbed” to hear of the threats saying the response in support of the amendment had been “astounding”.
She told councillors that by supporting the hunt “we are condoning their actions and bringing this council into disrepute.”
“People will no longer put up with hunts parading through their towns when they are persistently flouting hunting laws,” she said.
“This council should not be supporting any organisation that has links to criminal activity,” she added.
During the debate opposing councillors argued the motion would not comply with the Nolan principles – the seven principles of public life expected of public office – or the code of conduct.
They also said it would be undemocratic.
Former Grantham mayor and Charter Trustee member Ray Wootten said the hunt, which has run for more than 130 years, was a tradition which attracted hundreds of people.
He said there had been “no police presence until three years ago when protestors turned up”.
He, and wife Linda, both spoke of threats councillors had been received by hunt objectors.
Councillors were told “we know where you live” and called “evil scum”
They included councillors being told “We know where you live” and called “evil scum”.
He said the hunt itself had been called “bloodthirsty morons” and people had posted they “hope they fall off their horse and break their necks”.
Earlier in the meeting, Kit Henson, from Belvoir Hunt, told councillors it had “continued to operate within the law after the 2004 hunting act came into force.”
He said the hunt itself had not been prosecuted and “continue to operate at the highest standards”.
“It is a family-friendly festive tradition and it should not be stopped because of the regrettable action of one individual,” he said.”
Polly Portwin, Head of Hunting at the Countryside Alliance said: “We are delighted that the Council voted against the motion to ‘sever all ties with the Belvoir Hunt’ and therefore permit the hounds to meet in Grantham on Boxing Day.
“It is a great shame that councillors had to waste time on such a pointless and divisive debate but we are very grateful they rejected the proposal, even though we understand that some came under incredible pressure from anti-hunting activists.”
SUBSCRIBE TO LOCAL DEMOCRACY WEEKLY, our exclusive email newsletter with highlights from coverage every week, as well as insights and analysis from our local democracy reporters.