United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust has been placed into “special measures” after a report into care and mortality rates at 14 health trusts.
Out of the 14 trusts, 11 of them, including ULHT, have been placed under special measures by the Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt.
The special measures mean a task force will be placed within ULHT to help improve patient care.
The trust then be reviewed again at a later date. If conditions do not improve, the trust’s chief executive, board of governors and medical directors could all risk losing their roles.
The Keogh review
The measures were put into effect after a report led by Sir Bruce Keogh, in which a panel visited ULHT to access the quality of care within the trust’s three hospitals (Lincoln County Hospital, Pilgrim Hospital and Grantham Hospital).
The visits were part of a nationwide review into 14 NHS trusts with high mortality rates between 2010 and 2012, after the Mid-Staffordshire Hospitals scandal.
The report has noted it found a number of good points about care and they way in which hospitals were managed in Lincolnshire, but also saw a number of issues that needed urgent action.
This included:
A lack of communication between leadership at board level and leadership at clinical levels
A lack of clear management dealing with deteriorating patients and patient flow
A confusing patient complaints system
A lack of interest in patient experience
Low staffing levels at certain times of the day
Workforce planning is poor with no recruitment plans and no plans in place to cover maternity leave, sickness and annual leave
Quality strategy is not consistently articulated by staff
In regards to treatment of elderly patients, there was a lack of awareness of the Mental Capacity and Deprivation of Liberty Act 2005. This is in relation to the Trust’s responsibilities in allowing patients to leave wards if deemed capable or wish to do so.
Poor pain control
Issues in completing patient DNAR (Do Not Attempt Resuscitation) forms
A number of these issues were considered in urgent need of response by the trust, or something that the trust should start developing an action plan for.
Some issues were more ingrained into certain hospitals over others. For instance, A&E in Boston displayed good examples of the escalation process, but Lincoln A&E did not make use of the ambulance inbound information to plan capacity needs due to “IT issues”.
This was also leading to improper use of certain wards when patients were transferred. The panel saw one example of an elderly orthopaedic patient being transferred to a ward where staff were not familiar with a brace being worn, leading to another move for the patient.
At a bed management meeting in Lincoln County Hospital, there was no discussion regarding capacity required for the next 12 hour period and no evidence of forward planning to ensure capacity planning for overnight.
The trust had a written escalation plan, but this was not used at the meeting, despite not having enough beds available. This led to the outlying of patients — a primary option for the trust.
Staffing within the trust was also a concern for the panel, after witnessing a lack in nurses in all hospitals, meaning patients who require one-on-one care might not be able to receive it.
In one instance, there were three members of staff to cover a ward of 32 patients.
Some members of staff were also working past their shifts to make sure patients received the correct care they needed.
Full acceptance
ULHT has stated it fully accepts the findings within the review on its care within hospitals.
ULHT’s Chief Executive Jane Lewington said: “The safety and quality of patient care is our top priority. We have always seen the review as an opportunity to continue our journey of improvement.
“The review has helped to ensure that our efforts are targeting the changes that will make the most impact on patient care. Therefore we fully accept the findings.
“Patients are the very heart of everything we do, but others are doing better and therefore we need to learn from them.”
The trust is currently working to improve measures it has been flagged up on, with a focus on the level of staffing.
Recently, the trust pledged to spend £7 million on around 200 more nurses to meet with the demands of patients.
Jane Lewington added: “We will be unrelenting in our efforts to improve in the areas which the review panel have identified.
“But it also important that the review has recognised the excellence of much of what we do, and the commitment of so many of our staff.”
Other actions the trust are aiming begin are public listening events, a patient-focussed overhaul of the complaints system with patients and experts in the field involved in the review, and internal campaigns to promote staff awareness of best clinical practice.
David Harding-Price, Secretary of the North Lincolnshire Branch of the Royal College of Nursing, said “We take this review incredibly seriously and nationally the RCN have detailed examples of where we have raised concerns about patient safety in trusts.
“There is an undeniable link between nurse staffing levels and patient mortality and we cannot keep failing to address this issue. Only with the right numbers of nurses, with the right skills, can we ensure patients are looked after with dignity and compassion.”
He added “Sir Bruce Keogh’s review identifies key risk factors and warning signs to show where, and why, some trusts are underperforming including United Lincolnshire Health NHS Trust and the steps that urgently need to be taken to improve standards of patient care and safety.”
In a statement at the beginning of the review, Sir Bruce Keogh said: “We found pockets of excellent practice in all 14 of the trusts reviewed. However, we also found significant scope for improvement, with each needing to address an urgent set of actions in order to raise standards of care.
“These organisations have been trapped in mediocrity, which I am confident can be replaced by a sense of ambition if we give staff the confidence to achieve excellence.
“This is consistent with the ambitions that I know the new clinical commissioning groups have for their local populations and the legal duties they have to secure continuous improvements in the quality of services provided to patients.”
Areas of good care in Lincolnshire included:
Dedicated, committed and loyal staff
Monthly mortality reviews with good staff attendance
The Interim Director of Nursing has provided strong leadership to the nursing team and Matrons at all sites displayed strong leadership
Many wards displayed safety thermometer data sets
Plan for every patient on wards
Evidence of innovation e.g. Red Lid Scheme for Hydration/medication; phlebotomy service at weekends which takes pressure off junior doctors
Annual patient listening event in Lincoln, and patient experience and stories are part of Trust Board meetings
Safety and quality dashboards displayed on the wards
Proactive work around dementia in particular wards
To read the full report, visit The Keogh Mortality Review NHS page.
The Lincolnite welcomes your views. All comments are reactively-moderated and must obey the house rules. Please stay on topic and be respectful of other readers.
The 2024 Lincolnshire Business Excellence Awards are now open for nominations, seeking to spotlight outstanding businesses within the Greater Lincolnshire area.
Hosted by Stonebow Media, the publisher behind The Lincolnite and the MyLocal platform, this prestigious event is designed to honour the achievements of the regional business community.
Thanks to the headline sponsorship from the University of Lincoln Enterprise & Research department, the Lincolnshire Business Excellence Awards are a unique opportunity to acknowledge and celebrate the contributions of local enterprises.
The awards are also sponsored by Ringrose Law, Duncan & Toplis, Sills & Betteridge and Pearson Hydraulics. A small number of sponsorship opportunities remain available. Contact [email protected] to discuss partnerships.
Businesses can nominate themselves across eleven awards categories:
The deadline for nominations is May 24, with the judges’ deliberation lunch set for May 29.The judging panel includes business experts and professionals from Lincolnshire and event sponsors.
The Lincolnshire Business Excellence Awards 2024 gala will take place at the Engine Shed on July 12, 2024.
Enhance profile & credibility: Securing an award or being shortlisted acts as a powerful endorsement, signaling trustworthiness to potential customers and helping to distinguish your business from competitors. Displaying the award on your communications can significantly boost your brand’s perception.
Insightful focus & feedback: The application process encourages deep reflection on your business strategy and direction, offering invaluable feedback and clarity, even for new ventures.
Team confidence boost: Recognition from the awards can significantly uplift your team’s morale, affirming the value and potential of your business in the eyes of industry experts.
Marketing & PR boost: Being associated with the awards, even as a nominee, can enhance brand visibility, providing ample content opportunities for social media and other marketing channels.
Networking opportunities: The awards connect you with local business leaders and experts, offering a platform to seek advice, share ideas, and foster future partnerships. The ceremony itself is an excellent occasion for networking with peers and celebrating mutual successes.
Potential to win: Entering offers a chance to win and gain all the associated benefits, but even without taking home a trophy, the process can yield significant advantages for your business.
A Lady Gaga loving kitten owned by a couple who run a charity for disabled pets featured on Channel 5’s The Pet Psychic.
Pet Psychic Beth Lee-Crowther comes to the aid of pet owners and in Tuesday night’s episode she met Cookie the kitten, a depressed camel, and looked at whether a dog can predict the future.